Late Modernity and Its Tricks

Desire, fear, algorithmic overlords, and making philosophical peace with betrayal.

I. 

A Tuesday in November.

It is a truth universally acknowledged that a modern man in possession of a bathroom shelf must be in want of a toner. So the other day, I impulse-bought some facial toning water. It costs slightly more than an expensive sandwich and smells of almost nothing, something marketing has dubbed “arctic”. It took me an afternoon, and a short crisis of faith, to establish what it does and in what order it must be applied: after the cleanser, before the moisturiser, and never, under any circumstances, after the serum. It is not, on the face of it, a philosophical object. But at the till, I did a small and unwelcome sum.

Foam. Razors. Shampoo. Face wash. Moisturiser. The haircut every five weeks. Serums someone online promised would close my pores, which remain, as far as I can tell, open for business. The toner. Not to mention my gym subscription, two wellness apps that rapid-fire notifications reminding me to be less distracted. A Palo Santo stick, lit once a week to purify the energy of a one-bedroom flat, which now smells faintly of a rainforest and strongly of a domestic fire. You get the drift, and what’s funny is that your own shelf and routines may be longer, in which case add to the list and weep. My point is, that compounded over a year, all this becomes a tax I pay voluntarily, on time, with something close to a self-indulgent, insecure, naive pleasure. 

I am becoming, it turns out, a modest participant in this decade’s zeitgeist. Dictionary.com has named “maxxing” 2026’s word of the year: the habit of optimising some corner of life to its limit. There is looksmaxxing for the face, moneymaxxing for bank balances, cozymaxxing for couches. There is also auramaxxing, which I cannot distinguish from aurafarming, and the same shortlist helpfully supplied a word for people like me: “unc”. The dictionary noted that maxxing is used both earnestly and joklingly at our own expense, which seems exactly right. We know the pursuit is absurd, and we pursue it anyway.

This is not a novelty. In The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life, Erving Goffman argued that social life is a kind of theatre, with a downstage where we perform a role we wholly inhabit and a backstage where we take the costume off. At the till, I was not buying toner so much as a small promise: that if the surface were right, I would feel right and look right to others. That promise is the subject of this essay. Yes, it’s old and never kept, and our decade has found more ingenious ways of making it than any before. Therefore, I should say at the outset that I am not writing from outside the trap, but peeping from a skeptic’s bathroom window. I don’t know where to situate myself in the bigger picture.

Because there are no defined origins for the diverse modernities we now endure. Europeans like to date it to their Industrial Revolution to steam, print and the confident machinery of tomorrow. But the sense of living in a world unlike any before, arrived everywhere, at different times and in different accents. It came to Bengal through the printing press and the reformer’s pamphlet, to Meiji Japan as a deliberate national project, to Istanbul through Ottoman tanzimat, to Beijing with the students of 1919. To many European colonies it came via railways, censuses and colonial ledgers, imposed as often as it was embraced. Eisenstadt taught us to speak of “multiple modernities”, since each society took the new ideas and interpreted them differently. Yet beneath these variations laid a consistency of wagers. The future would be better than the past. Reason and technology would master nature. The individual could choose their being. And happiness was to be pursued, produced and, eventually, (through America) bought. 

By this late “modernity” or what some scholars have called metamodernity I refer less to a period and more to the renewed faith that satisfaction can be assembled from the outside in; by improving circumstances, accumulation and extending control. In 2010 cultural theorists, Timotheus Vermeulen and Robin van den Akker, proposed metamodernism for a sensibility that fluctuates between modern enthusiasm and postmodern irony: a kind of informed naivety. We have read the critiques; we know the serum won’t close any pores. We buy it anyway, half-joking and wholly in earnest, which is exactly how the dictionary says we use the word maxxing.

In this century this wager has rapidly gone global and digital at once. A teenager in Lagos, a retiree in Osaka and a commuter in São Paulo carry the same device, scroll the same feeds and feel the same small tug of notifications. Modernity no longer emerges from metropolises and spreads outward. It is the air, and, like air, is hardest to notice at the moment it is everywhere.

II.

In this invisible modern air that surrounds us, we think this meal, this purchase, this body, this holiday, this person: this will satiate us, and not in the temporary, meaningless way of the last one. That is the promise, and we fall for it like clockwork. Psychologists, for ages, call this cycle a hedonic treadmill. We adapt to each new pleasure with dispiriting speed, return to roughly where we started, and yearn again from a new default. I can report that the toner is nearly forgotten, and that holds true for everything I once pursued with hellish lust. 

What makes the lie so captivating is that it’s never quite false. This meal is delicious. This holiday is lovely. This body is warm. The world does relieve us; it simply does not reveal what we’re relieved from, or grant what the pleasure promised. We fall for a folly like those in Plato’s cave—in taking the shadows for the whole of what is real, and in organising life around catching them, understanding them, and decorating them. 

In this process of decoration, modern life is now perhaps a spectacle in which everything once directly lived, has receded into a representation. An image generator can produce, at 3 AM, a beach bluer than any sea, posted by an account with nobody, liked by accounts with no bodies behind them. The shadows have never been more vivid or more plentiful, as the personalised spectacle of the cave wall learns our likes and feeds us more and more and more.

If the senses and stimulation are the first lure, ideas are the second, and the subtler. We grow attached not only to things and pleasures but to concepts: opinions about politics and love and diet and parenting and justice. To theories of who we are, or must be, to a picture of how we should live. We defend these attachments like they’re our limbs, yet in hindsight, they never seem to be truly ours at all. René Girard argued that human desire is mimetic. We do not simply want; we want what we see other people wanting. The same is true of what we think and Heidegger had a name for the progenitor of most of our opinions: das Man, “the they”, or simply “one”. One wears this. One thinks that. One is outraged by the inflammatory. We take ourselves to be reasoning when, much of the time, we repeat, or simply reframe that which we’ve learnt and adopted from others.

For most of history, the models for our desires and accomplishments were a few dozen neighbours. Be the best guitarist in the area and people will hear about you at the local cafe and probably show up to hear you play. Now through our handhelds, you must compete with the best global talents in music, all at once. Collins has made “mogging” its word of the year: to outshine someone, usually with a smirk. Our opinions arrive pre-chewed, in thirty-second clips, and we know there will always be someone who ‘mogs’ us. We are reminded of it with every scroll, like and comment. 

A great deal of modern misery is this second-hand kind. The cost of borrowing, comparing and self-evaluating not only makes us less satisfied, but also less original. Imitation becomes the clearest way to get what the ‘other’ has and frames our desire. Reality has no obligation to match our superimposed expectations, and when it doesn’t, we suffer. But could one argue that this is unique to modernity?

III.

Beneath this very attachment to outcomes and ideas lies a natural human hunger: the wish to know what happens next. For four years. I have lived in The Netherlands, a small country that runs on a clean, flat logic. The Dutch spent centuries persuading the sea to stay put, and appear to have applied the same engineering to social life. Bicycle lanes are pristine, social contracts are hilariously explicit, schedules are stiff as a board and where one stands has been agreed in advance. One must live and let live, or die. 

In 1929 John Dewey published The Quest for Certainty, arguing that much of Western philosophy had been an elaborate attempt to escape the anxiety of a random, uncertain world. We built systems of thought, he suggested, the way frightened people build walls. Perhaps that is why, in the subsequent decades, the West was intrigued by the spiritualism of the East, where people were more at ease with unawareness and ready to embrace a Divine drama or ‘Leela’.

Meanwhile, apps and bots are tracking parcels like little ants crawling across a map. We check the rain hour by hour, the heart rate minute by minute, the sleep score each morning, and I have learned to feel tired when the score says so. And this year, the quest for certainty found its purest modern form in the prediction market. Platforms that let you bet on almost anything (elections, interest rates, the weather, award ceremonies, the next James Bond) now move billions a week. Tarek Mansour, a co-founder of Kalshi, has described the long-term vision as to “financialize everything”.

These markets gather scattered knowledge better than most pundits. But notice what they actually sell— no one can remove perceived uncertainty, so it simply gets monetised. They turn the unknown instant into a ticker you can watch, and so give the mind the feeling of grip sans substance. Kierkegaard called anxiety “the dizziness of freedom”: the vertigo of standing before a future that is truly open. Next month, Avengers: Doomsday will be released as a testament against this uncertainty. Having the Marvel Cinematic Universe be a constant for almost two decades ought to be a reassurance, a stability for the general public. To them, knowing the future of blockbuster cinema–of entertainment–is in the hands of capes and IPs would be as satisfying as the little dots on the screen. 

IV.

And here comes the promised bargain of modernism. If we cannot have certainty, we would settle for freedom from fear. Modernity was supposed to be the period in human history when the fears that pervaded social life in the past would be abandoned and human beings at last, take control of their lives; taming the uncontrolled forces of the social and natural worlds. That failed terribly. 

Zygmunt Bauman described ours as an age of “liquid fear”: a diffuse, free-floating dread that no longer attaches to a single enemy, like wolves or plague, but seeps in from everywhere at once: the job market, the climate, the news, the machines, the nudes we once shared. While earlier ages feared particulars, we fear the general, and the general’s inescapable. 

Generation Alpha is the first to grow up entirely inside the screen, and the adult world has belatedly panicked. Australia banned under-16s from most social media at the end of 2025. Indonesia and Malaysia followed this year, and Britain has announced it will do the same. Whatever the bans’ merits, they are also a confession. We built a world that frightens our children, and now we are frightened on their behalf.

As for the adults, I can only speak for one. AI answers almost any question instantly (at times, sycophantically), which is both marvellous and also makes not-knowing harder to bear. We have asked a chatbot things at two in the morning that we wouldn’t ask a friend at two in the afternoon. The research so far points both ways. One study this year found that a conversation with an AI companion eased loneliness in the moment about as well as talking to a person; a Stanford study this summer found that people with few social ties who leaned on AI for emotional support ended up with lower wellbeing. The machine, it seems, soothes the fear tonight and deepens it over the year. 

Don’t call me an alarmist, yet. I would not give any of this tech back. Socrates worried that writing would ruin memory. Novels were accused of corrupting the young, and radio and television of rotting the national mind. Meanwhile the modern world has delivered what no earlier age could: longer lives, far fewer children dying, more than a billion people lifted out of extreme poverty, and a phone that lets a grandmother in one hemisphere watch her grandchild’s first steps in another. Nothing here is an argument that technology is the enemy, or that some earlier age was wiser. My claim is that the trap was always there, but our century, our decade, especially, has made it quicker and easier to get ensnared without realising.

V.

To dissect if the said ensnaring is best for us, it may help to think of ourselves as divided, not between body and spirit, which sounds too grand, but between two parts of our own experience. There is the mind: restless, chattering, grasping, forever comparing, planning, regretting and reaching for the next thing. And there is the spirit, or conscience, or divinity, if I may, that watches the mind do all this and remains undisturbed. It always knows what’s right for us at the moment. For most of history the balance was kept, roughly, by circumstance. There were long walks, long waits, dull evenings, silences that could not be filled. The mind had its way, even then, but it had to wait. Twenty years ago, if you wanted to know what a word meant, you lifted down a dictionary worthy of doorstopping and thumbed through the alphabet, getting distracted by better words on the way. A fact meant a trip to the library, the right floor, the right shelf, the book that was out and the one beside it that turned out to be better. A song heard once on the radio might take weeks to find: a hummed fragment to a friend, a visit to the record shop, a finger hovering over the record button in case it came on again. It wasn’t efficient, but it gave immense joy in retrospect. The effort made us want the thing a little longer before we had it, and that wanting was itself a form of learning. 

A desire satisfied the instant it arises never has time to become more than a whim. Something else deep inside us, which grew in the waiting, is discarded, because waiting is now sub-zero. Every gap is filled, every question answered, every craving met within the hour and often within the minute. Do we have the right to complain about getting exactly what we want? I leave that to you. 

Either way, the algorithm cares not what we need, only that we stay, and our mind is delighted to oblige. So what is one to do? Where is the escape? Retreating to a cabin is a fantasy for most people and a pose for many of the rest. Yet bills arrive, children need collecting and shaving foam runs out. Any philosophy worth having must work on a Tuesday. 

Albert Camus opened The Myth of Sisyphus by asking whether life, being absurd, is worth living, and concluded that it is, because one can refuse both despair and false hope and meaning. A hidden, deeper meaning is not necessary and like this article, chaotic is fine, too. One must, although, try to maintain that the world was never offering the deal we assumed. The senses give pleasure, and pleasure passes. Ideas give us somewhere to stand, and the ground shifts. The future won’t be known in advance, and no app will abolish our existential dread. One can hold an opinion lightly, the way a guest holds a borrowed coat. One can face the unknown next moment with a carefree smirk. And then one can turn, for a few minutes a day, from the mind’s noise toward the part that has been watching all along, waiting to be noticed.. It’s not glamorous, it’s not meant to be shown to others, and it cannot be maxxed. 

Each morning, hot tap water runs in my washroom until the mirror fogs, and I wipe a clearing in it with the side of my hand. The toner helplessly waits on the shelf for its turn. I lather up and see the face I will present to this glorious world of late modernity once again. But lately, I try to remember, for a quick second, that the face is a costume and the mirror is simply a mirror. Such is life. The fatal flaw of our world is not really that it lies to us; the world has always made promises it wouldn’t keep. But if we’re to fall for these fleeting assurances, let’s do so with our eyes wide open and, dare I say, a grin on our faces.

Yuvraj Nathani
Yuvraj Nathani

Yuvraj Nathani is Founding Editor at ALMA Magazine. Raised in a small town in northern India, he moved into global media and advertising before launching ALMA in 2020 — born from a desire to create a world-class, independent literary and arts platform from South Asia. Outside the editor’s desk, he’s a jazz piano tinkerer, a fiction reader across continents, and a believer in stories that travel lighter than borders. For more, follow him here.